Darcy Benoit and her son know this danger all too effectively. Benoit can also be a rape survivor and mother or father to a toddler conceived from rape. She says that legal guidelines permitting rapists the chance to get custody fail to grasp that in suing for baby custody, it’s not about rapists eager to co-parent a toddler a lot as taking revenge on their victims. These legal guidelines primarily permit perpetrators to stay tethered to their victims so rapists can proceed to train energy over them. As a resident of Arizona, Benoit lacked a conviction in her rape case to guard herself and her baby; she was compelled to co-parent along with her rapist for greater than eight years.
“It’s simply been hell—I’ve been stalked, harassed, tormented, and so has my son,” she mentioned. “I’ve had protecting orders on him, however they expire yearly, and he violates them usually.”
Limiting rapists’ entry to baby custody
Modifications to current legal guidelines that permit rapists to sue their victims for baby custody have largely relied on the efforts of survivors like Analyn Megison. She was raped in 2003, and since her attacker’s violence triggered her to blackout, she solely realized she had been assaulted when she discovered she was pregnant. In 2010, when Megison and her daughter had been Florida residents, her rapist (who hadn’t been convicted for raping Megison) tried to sue for custody—years after the kid was born.
“I discovered that there was actually nothing in place in Florida to stop this, which was actually scary,” she mentioned.
A lawyer by commerce, Megison determined to draft a mannequin legislation to stop any visitation or parental rights of the rapist over a toddler conceived by rape. The invoice was handed unanimously and with bipartisan assist in 2013 and requires the usual of “clear and convincing evidence” for a rapist’s parental rights to be terminated.
The invoice’s existence got here at nice private price to Megison. As a single mom, she was “working across the state to testify in courtroom and talk about her trigger” whereas concurrently combating her rapist in courtroom to stop him from having access to her daughter. As well as, she was additionally coping with an abusive ex-husband and was pregnant with one other baby.
“I used to be in a scenario the place I used to be making an attempt to boost consciousness actually whereas being in hiding,” she mentioned. “It was an uphill battle. I used to be form of alone.”
However Megison wasn’t on her personal in her newest efforts to alter laws to assist different rape survivors. Together with Benoit and different survivors, their advocacy pushed Arizona to turn out to be the newest state to pass legislation in 2021, adopting the same civil customary to Florida’s the place a legal conviction for rape isn’t required to sever the parental rights of alleged rapists who impregnate their victims. Like Megison, Benoit’s experiences of injustice drove her to press for authorized change.
“I began speaking to everybody I might discover,” Benoit mentioned. “I talked to the Senate, I might discuss to representatives, I might discuss at universities, I might discuss at faculties, I might discuss to different social staff, and I might inform my tales.”
Benoit’s persistence ultimately satisfied state Sen. Victoria Steele to sponsor the House Bill. Presently, 14 states—Colorado, Connecticut, Florida, Georgia, Hawaii, Indiana, Iowa, Maine, Maryland, Michigan, Mississippi, South Dakota, Texas, and Vermont—terminate parental rights of a rapist primarily based on the civil customary of clear and convincing proof. These states are supported by the federal Rape Survivor Child Custody Act (RSCCA), which authorizes the U.S. legal professional normal to make grants to states that move laws terminating the parental rights of males who father youngsters by way of rape. States should use the “clear and convincing proof” customary, which is the predominant customary within the U.S. for termination of parental rights, to find out whether or not the daddy dedicated rape. The “clear and convincing” authorized customary signifies that the proof being introduced have to be “extremely” and considerably extra possible to be true somewhat than unfaithful. Presently, nevertheless, solely 32 states permit the termination of parental rights of rapists who conceive a toddler, whereas others have various restrictions in place, and lots of nonetheless require a criminal conviction.
Many survivors imagine that altering authorized requirements to terminate parental rights for rapists is simply the beginning of what survivors should be protected and guarded. Benoit is intimately conscious of each the necessity for and limitations of present authorized protections for survivors and their households. She is a part of the Arizona Address Confidentiality Program, which implies her rapist isn’t imagined to know the place she lives. Nevertheless, he’s managed to search out her two instances, necessitating her relocation 3 times up to now. Not solely is that this upsetting and troubling for her household, it’s additionally a substantial monetary and psychological effort to repeatedly begin over and never know for certain that her rapist received’t have any entry to them once more.
Survivors nonetheless bear vital monetary and social prices to guard their households
Whereas legislative change will help ease the authorized burdens borne by rape survivors, there’s little that laws can do to minimize the social and emotional prices rape survivors are made to pay within the wake of their assaults. Having to begin over after a rape is tough sufficient—doing so after conceiving because of rape is much more complicated. And the onus to guard oneself stays on the survivor.
Laurel, a primary technology immigrant, was 26 when she met a person at a non secular occasion who ultimately raped her. She conceived twins after the rape and moved from Washington, D.C., to Florida, doing no matter she might to throw as many limitations as attainable between her rapist and any probability he might attempt to achieve custody of her youngsters.
“I made certain that he wouldn’t file for custody,” Laurel mentioned. “I made it as tough as I might presumably make it, on goal. You might want to get as distant from that individual having authorized entry to you as attainable.”
This was simpler mentioned than completed. Laurel needed to work three jobs to assist herself and her twins. The stress was so extreme that she grew to become ailing and needed to be hospitalized. She was afraid of placing her full identify on social media, fearing her rapist may discover her handle or contact data. Like many survivors, Laurel discovered few protections or assets in place to assist rebuild her life. Furthermore, when she went to medical professionals for assist, as a substitute of compassionate care, she was usually met with judgment.
“I used to be guilted by virtually everybody, together with the medical institution, to maintain a being pregnant that was not in my greatest curiosity,” she mentioned.
Laurel believes that medical and social personnel want higher coaching on how one can deal thoughtfully and respectfully with rape survivors, each to make sure survivors’ bodily well being and entry to the psychological well being and authorized help they want. That is additionally true for police and different legislation enforcement, who usually look on survivors with suspicion as a substitute of assist and sometimes don’t give rape instances their full attention.
“Coping with police, the detectives, it was a horrible expertise,” Benoit mentioned. “I used to be not handled like a sufferer.”
Kendra Geronimo, a survivor of human trafficking who handled a rape-related being pregnant, thinks there may be an pressing want for the mentality round rape to alter, particularly within the police drive. She advocates for extra compassion, understanding, and due diligence in investigations as a substitute of simply brushing apart of rape instances, which has been her expertise.
“Folks have a look at rape victims like we’re both one thing to really feel sorry for, or there’s this suspicion that we is probably not telling the reality,” Geronimo mentioned. “Quite a lot of issues that police brushed apart might have been invaluable proof. After which years later, you don’t have proof to face on as a result of they didn’t do due diligence, as a result of their mentality was tousled.”
Geronimo can also be advocating for rising the statute of limitation on rape, which varies in Florida, the place she resides, primarily based on the age of the sufferer and nature of the crime. She believes {that a} longer statute of limitations would have helped her file a case afterward, when she had a while and distance from the incident and was not coping with a being pregnant. She additionally conducts instructional seminars on how one can determine intercourse trafficking and helps to rescue and monitor down lacking women by way of Liberation Team, a nonprofit she began.
Regardless of her in depth advocacy, she admits that she has been very afraid to talk publicly about her experiences as a result of her son shouldn’t be but of age. She believes that she’s going to really feel much less threatened when her son is eighteen, and she’s going to have the ability to have a louder, stronger voice. For now, nevertheless, she does what she will to assist different survivors with out placing herself or her son in jeopardy.
Different survivors have averted talking publicly and even becoming a member of efforts to alter rape and custody-related legal guidelines out of comparable worries about attracting consideration and adverse repercussions. And people worries aren’t unfounded. Each time Megison spoke publicly about this problem, or made any vital progress, her abusive ex-husband would make it tough for her to see her son. She needed to always remind herself that the combat was price it and would ultimately carry her and her youngsters to a greater place.
“I can not fathom the concept persons are saying I ought to maintain parenting with a rapist,” Alana mentioned. “The identical issues that make you a rapist are what make you an unfit mother or father.”
Her rape case by no means acquired any closure, and he or she’s nonetheless co-parenting along with her rapist, which is triggering and severely damaging for her psychological well being. The justice system in her state, which requires legal conviction of the rapist to terminate a rapist’s parental rights, continues to be unable to adequately assist her.
“I’m not so naïve to suppose that telling my fact wouldn’t come at a value, however I didn’t suppose that the authorized system would damage me as badly as my rapist,” she mentioned.
*Identify has been modified to guard the identification of the survivor.
Nayanika Guha is a contract author who writes about social justice, identification, and neighborhood. She has a background in psychology and social work, which informs her writing and worldview. Her work has appeared in The Guardian, The Lily, Refinery 29, and extra. Comply with her on Twitter @nayanikawrites.
Prism is a BIPOC-led nonprofit information outlet that facilities the folks, locations, and points presently underreported by nationwide media. We’re dedicated to producing the form of journalism that treats Black, Indigenous, and folks of coloration, girls, the LGBTQ+ neighborhood, and different invisibilized teams because the specialists on our personal lived experiences, our resilience, and our fights for justice. Sign up for our email list to get our tales in your inbox, and observe us on Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram.
